Sports disciplinary regimes, like broader governance regimes, need flexible rules. That flexibility only works, however, if decisions made under it are sound and reasonably predictable.
The AFL Appeals Board’s decision to overturn Lachie Neale’s grand final suspension under the AFL’s new “exceptional and compelling circumstances” clause shows what happens when they are not. A discretion intended to reward exemplary records produced an outcome at odds with every comparable sanction that season, and it did so because the clause left its key terms undefined.
This article examines the Neale decision, the clause that enabled it, and the lessons it holds for any sporting organisation drafting discretion into its code: the limits of that discretion must be set at the drafting table, not in the hearing room.
The Lachie Neale Drama
At the beginning of the AFL’s grand final week, Lachie Neale was suspended for one game after striking Hawthorn player Jack Ginnivan in the stomach during the preliminary final. The suspension would have ruled him out of the AFL grand final.
Neale’s action was graded as intentional conduct, medium impact and body contact. Under the AFL’s 2026 guidelines, that grading carries a one-match suspension.
The Brisbane Lions challenged this suspension at the AFL Tribunal. They advanced three arguments:
the hit on Ginnivan was not a strike, but rather a “bump, a body check”;
if it was a strike, it was low impact rather than medium; and
even if the charge was made out, Neale’s record of never having been suspended across 320 games amounted to “exceptional and compelling circumstances” warranting a fine instead.
The Tribunal rejected all three contentions.
The Lions then appealed to the AFL Appeals Board on the basis that the Tribunal had made an error of law.
The Appeals Board found that the Tribunal erred by having regard to whether the conduct was intentional. Intention was an element of the charge that had already been established. The relevant question was only whether Neale’s record constituted exceptional and compelling circumstances warranting a lesser sanction.
The Appeals Board was satisfied that Neale’s record was “exemplary” and constituted exceptional and compelling circumstances. The one-match suspension was set aside and replaced with a $10,000 fine.
Neale played, and Brisbane won its third consecutive premiership.
The “Exceptional And Compelling Circumstances” Clause
The AFL introduced this clause this season. It provides that players will not automatically receive a reduced sanction for a good record; however, a player with an exemplary record whose offence is contested or referred to the Tribunal may argue that their record constitutes exceptional and compelling circumstances.
This discretionary power is not without merit. Its utility was demonstrated in March this season, when it was used to downgrade Scott Pendlebury’s suspension. Before that incident, Pendlebury had never faced the Tribunal or been suspended in his 21-year career.
That decision is a good example of how flexibility in sports governance can be effective. It allowed a salient factor, in this instance Pendlebury’s exemplary record, to be weighed by the Tribunal in what would otherwise be a rigid system of automatic sanctions.
At first instance, the Tribunal distinguished Pendlebury’s case from Neale’s on the basis that the former’s conduct was careless while the latter’s was intentional. The Appeals Board held that this distinction was irrelevant to the clause.
The Outcome
The outcome sits uneasily with the rest of the season’s sanctions. Before the appeal, AFL football boss Greg Swann noted that there had been ten gut punches in 2026, and that each had resulted in a one-match suspension. Neale’s became the exception.
The difficulty, then, is not that the discretion exists, but that it is unstructured. The clause does not state what an exemplary record is, whether intentional conduct is excluded, or how much weight a record should carry.
Neale’s record also shows how unevenly a flexible rule can be applied. Like Pendlebury, he had never been suspended across a lengthy career. Unlike Pendlebury, however, Neale had been found guilty of eight offences, three of them for striking an opponent’s body. His record qualified on the wording of the clause. Whether it should have is a question the clause leaves entirely to whoever hears the case.
Discretion Is A Governance Decision
This case is not really about Lachie Neale. It is about who decides where discretion can and cannot be exercised. Without predictability built into a sporting organisation’s code, that decision falls to its tribunals, who must make it case by case, under pressure and without clear guidance.
The AFL is better placed than most sporting organisations to absorb the risk that discretion poses. It has KC-chaired tribunals, a standing appeals body, and significant financial resources. Most national and state sporting organisations do not; consequently, undefined discretion and inconsistent decision making carry a greater risk for such bodies.
For any organisation building flexibility into its code, the work happens at the drafting table. That means identifying the factors a decision maker may consider, stating whether certain conduct is excluded, defining what constitutes an “exemplary record”, and reviewing the provision after its first uses rather than after its first controversy.
Flexible rules are only as good as the decision-making framework which supports them. A governing body that builds discretion into its code also needs to set out where that discretion starts and stops.